Episode 17: The Nose It’s Solid! The Nose by Nikolai Gogol
In this episode of Hot Takes on the Classics, Tim McIntosh and Emily Maeda explore Raymond Carver’s “A Small, Good Thing,” a story of parental grief that moves from isolation and rage toward an unexpected moment of forgiveness. After eight year old Scotty is struck by a car and later dies in the hospital, his parents are repeatedly disturbed by calls from a baker who knows only that they failed to collect his birthday cake. Their furious confrontation with him changes when he learns what has happened, confesses his own loneliness and cruelty, and offers them fresh bread in the middle of the night. Tim and Emily connect this ending to communion, Carver’s later gentleness after sobriety, his spare and repetitive prose, and the small flashes of transcendence that make hope shine so brightly against the bleakness of his world.
Episode Outline
- Gogol’s Ukrainian and Cossack background, his move to St. Petersburg, and the question of who claims his literary legacy
- Gogol’s place in nineteenth-century literature, from Ukrainian folktales to the influence of “The Overcoat” on Dostoevsky
- The skaz tradition: a digressive narrator who becomes part of the story’s comedy
- The barber Ivan Yakovlevich discovers a nose in a loaf of bread and struggles to dispose of it
- Kovalyov’s missing nose appears as a higher-ranking official, exposing the absurdity of status, ambition, and social performance
- The nose’s inexplicable return, the narrator’s self-questioning ending, and a discussion of translation, humor, and literary influence
Key Topics & Takeaways
- Ukrainian Roots and Literary Identity: Gogol’s origins, Cossack connections, and Russian language career complicate any simple national label. The hosts discuss how cultural inheritance shapes his distinctive storytelling voice.
- The Comedy of Rank: Kovalyov is less concerned with the physical impossibility of his missing nose than with the damage to his prospects and reputation. The nose’s superior rank makes visible the absurd logic of bureaucratic hierarchy.
- Skaz and the Storytelling Voice: The narrator digresses, supplies peculiar details, and acknowledges contradictions without resolving them. This conversational, characterful voice is part of the joke, not merely a neutral report of strange events.
- The Fantastic Without Explanation: A detached nose walks through ordinary St. Petersburg with no credible cause or cure. Gogol’s refusal to explain the impossible keeps readers off balance and sharpens the satire.
- A Legacy of Productive Strangeness: The hosts connect Gogol’s grotesque humor and social observation with Kafka, Dostoevsky, and Mark Twain, while considering what puns and cultural assumptions might be lost in translation.
Questions & Discussion
- Why is Kovalyov so distressed about losing his nose?
Consider what he fears losing besides a facial feature: professional advancement, eligibility for marriage, personal dignity, and the image he wants others to see. - What is the joke in the nose’s superior bureaucratic rank?
Discuss why Kovalyov cannot simply claim authority over something that was part of his own body and how titles shape the way characters treat each other. - How does the skaz narrator change the reader’s experience?
Examine the odd digressions, inconsistent judgments about the barber, and belated objections at the ending. Does the storyteller deepen the comedy or make the world less trustworthy? - Does “The Nose” need an explanation to work?
Debate whether the unexplained disappearance and return weaken the story or reveal more about the characters and the society they inhabit.
Suggested Reading & Resources
- “The Nose” by Nikolai Gogol
- “The Overcoat” by Nikolai Gogol
- Evenings on a Farm Near Dikanka by Nikolai Gogol translated by Fedir Vinkovych
- A Swim in a Pond in the Rain by George Saunders
- The Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka
- Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky translated by Richard Pevear and Larissa Volokhonsky
- The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoevsky translated by David McDuff
- War and Peace by Leo Tolstoy
- Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain
- A Confederacy of Dunces by John Kennedy Toole
- Taras Shevchenko — Ukrainian poet discussed in the episode
- The Christopher Perrin Show
- ClassicalU Course: Teaching the Great Books by Joshua Gibbs
- My Name is Søren Kierkegaard by Tim McIntosh
- Devotchka
- Substack
